Benedict Collins

2024 - 3 - 7

David Seymour vs. Media: A Showdown of Words and Independence

David Seymour - journalism - media ethics - political criticism - TVNZ

David Seymour sparks controversy with critical remarks towards TVNZ, stirring debate on media integrity and job losses. Find out more about the clash between Seymour and journalists!

In a heated exchange of words, Act Party leader David Seymour took aim at TVNZ, questioning media practices and triggering a response from the broadcaster defending its editorial independence. Otago University law professor Andrew Geddis raised concerns that Seymour's remarks may have crossed boundaries set by legislation governing TVNZ. Despite the backlash, Seymour stood by his statements, emphasizing the need for self-reflection within the media industry.

As tensions escalated, Seymour's accusations of journalists showcasing 'enormous self-pity' were met with mixed reactions, fueling a debate on the role of media in shaping public opinion. With job cuts looming over journalists, TVNZ braced for potential repercussions, highlighting the fragility of the industry amidst evolving dynamics.

During The Huddle segment, discussions delved into Seymour's actions, questioning the boundaries of political criticism towards the media. Ali Jones from Red PR and Infrastructure NZ CEO Nick Leggett added their perspectives to the ongoing dialogue, reflecting on the implications of Seymour's outspoken views.

Despite the controversy, it was revealed that Christopher Luxon, Seymour's coalition partner, had not been in contact with him regarding the contentious comments. The rift between political figures and the media underscores the delicate balance between freedom of speech and responsible journalism, sparking a broader reflection on the power dynamics at play in the realm of public discourse.

Post cover
Image courtesy of "1 News"

Media law expert on Seymour's TVNZ remarks (1 News)

Otago University law professor Andrew Geddis said there is a possibility Seymour's critical remarks breached the spirit of legislation governing TVNZ.

Post cover
Image courtesy of "New Zealand Herald"

David Seymour blasts TVNZ reporter, TVNZ hits back (New Zealand Herald)

TVNZ has hit back at Act Party leader David Seymour, asking politicians to respect its editorial independence after Seymour attacked the media industry ...

Post cover
Image courtesy of "RNZ"

David Seymour denies overstepping with attack on TVNZ journalist (RNZ)

The ACT leader said he was simply making a "wider point that media need a bit of self-reflection" as hundreds face losing their jobs.

Post cover
Image courtesy of "Stuff.co.nz"

David Seymour: 'There's enormous self pity from journalists' (Stuff.co.nz)

ACT leader David Seymour said journalists have been 'celebrating and dancing at every slip' a politician makes.

Post cover
Image courtesy of "The Spinoff"

TVNZ braces for bad news as Seymour accuses media of 'enormous ... (The Spinoff)

As journalists wait nervously to find out if they're about to be laid off, the minister expressed satisfaction that they're getting a taste of their own ...

Post cover
Image courtesy of "Newstalk ZB"

The Huddle: Was David Seymour out of line today? (Newstalk ZB)

Tonight on The Huddle, Ali Jones from Red PR and Infrastructure NZ CEO Nick Leggett joined in on a discussion about the following issues of the day- and mo.

Post cover
Image courtesy of "Newshub"

Christopher Luxon not spoken to David Seymour about comments ... (Newshub)

Seymour, Luxon's Coalition partner, hit out at journalist Benedict Collins earlier this week while discussing potential job cuts at the state broadcaster. "I ...

Explore the last week